A fun little project

Question: I was reading an article on how to write a good fantasy novel and I came across an idea that struck me as odd and was something I never thought of doing, but actually sounded like a pretty fun project to me. when the author of this article was saying how important originality is, he stated (rather rudely) that it would be a horrible idea to write a novel based around an rpg agme like DnD that you and your friends played. But I thought, what more unpredictable of a plot can you come up with? I thought, if nothing else, that it would make a very interesting venture to let the dice take you for a joyride through a fantasy world and put down your adventures on paper, especially if the game was started for the sole purpose of being fodder for a book. But I really want an expert's opinion. So what do you think? Any credibility? Thanks!

Answer: While it's not impossible to use such a game for inspiration, there are a number of pitfalls to watch for.

1. Who designed the dungeon? If you are the dungeon master and have written all the modules/adventures, that's one thing. But if someone else has then you would be violating their copyright. D&D is not a blank slate. The adventures are laid out by someone in advance, so they are actually quite predictable.

2. D&N and many other games - because they are just games - are often pretty shallow emotionally. Characters tend to be one-dimensional, and all with identical goals. Players
do not have to wrestle with nearly the range of issues in a game that they would in real life. They have nothing much at stake. Losing a character is no bigger loss than losing a sports trophy.

3. Similarly, people in real life do not tend to grow in power and skills the way they do in a game. Pain affects them more. They have interests that do not revolve around killing monsters, finding treasure, and gaining experience points - all of which are pure self-interest. In fact, you could argue that D&D characters are largely sociopathic.

4. D&D adventures do not have the same kind of story arc that a dramatic work of fiction does. The games are intended to be episodic. A character can theoretically go on forever, advancing from one quest to the next. Good fictional characters are driven by a need to resolve an inner problem. Once they have done so, their story essentially ends (happily or not).

5. Games are designed to be addictive, always dangling a carrot in front of the player. Real life doesn't do that.

Some writers have used tools not unlike what you're suggesting in order to give themselves a sequence of random bits of meaning or symbols out of which they can construct a story, but the best tools have more emotional and philosophical depth than RPGs. Tarot is one such tool. The I-Ching is another. Even astrology has more potential, IMHO.

Personally, I prefer the Dramatica software, since it was specifically designed with stories in mind (though it may be the most complex method).

Click here to post comments

Join in and submit your own question/topic! It's easy to do. How? Simply click here to return to Questions About Novel Writing.